Best Pillow for Back and Side Sleepers: What to Look For

Key takeaways

  • Side sleepers need more height to fill the space between the ear and the mattress. Back sleepers need less, so the head is not pushed forward.
  • If you use both positions, a pillow you can make lower or softer (and rebuild with the filling you kept) is more practical than a fixed one.
  • The Yourzzz pillow is adjusted after delivery. The calculator tells you how much filling to remove, and you have 100 nights to try it.

Why is it hard to find one pillow for back and side sleeping?

Most people do not stay in one position all night. You may fall asleep on your back, turn onto your side at some point, and wake up in a third position. Each position asks something different from a pillow.

When you lie on your side, your shoulder pushes into the mattress and your head sits well above it. The pillow has to fill that gap. If it is too low, your head tilts down toward the mattress. If it is too high, it tilts up and away from your shoulder.

When you lie on your back, there is much less space to fill. A pillow that is too high pushes your chin toward your chest. A pillow that is too low lets your head tip back.

That is why a pillow that feels right in one position can feel wrong in the other. A pillow is not like a mattress, where one firmness suits most of the body. The gap it has to fill depends on your shoulders, your neck and how far you sink into the bed.

What decides the right height for you?

Four things matter most:

  • Your body. Broader shoulders leave a bigger gap on your side. Height and weight both play a part.
  • Your sleeping position. Side, back or stomach, and especially the position you fall asleep in.
  • Your mattress. On a soft mattress your shoulder sinks in and the gap gets smaller. On a firm mattress the gap stays larger.
  • The pillow itself. The filling decides how much the pillow compresses under your head, so the height you buy is not always the height you sleep on.

You would not walk around in shoes a size too small. A pillow works the same way: a store that sells one size rarely has yours. For more on this, see our page on pillow height.

What does the research say?

We are not aware of research that shows one pillow height is best for back and side sleepers in general. Studies on pillows are small and often compare only a few products. So we do not promise that a certain loft prevents stiffness or pain. What we can say is simple: a pillow that fills the space between your head, neck and shoulder without bending your neck up, down or sideways gives your head steady support. That is the goal of a good fit, and it is what we describe here.

A pillow also will not fix everything. If your mattress is worn out or does not suit you, a better pillow only helps so much. If you wake up with pain, numbness or tingling, or the pain does not go away, see a healthcare provider. A pillow is not a treatment.

What should you look for in a pillow for back and side sleepers?

  1. Adjustable height. You should be able to take filling out and, ideally, put it back later. This matters most if your position, your mattress or your body changes over time.
  2. A filling that compresses predictably. Shredded memory foam is easy to adjust because you can remove it a little at a time. Our page on the shredded memory foam pillow explains how this works.
  3. A cover you can wash. A removable cover makes the pillow easier to keep fresh.
  4. A fair trial period. You only know whether a pillow fits after you have slept on it for a while.

If you want to read more about each position on its own, we have separate pages for side sleepers and back sleepers. If you switch a lot during the night, our page for combination sleepers goes further into that.

How does the Yourzzz pillow work for both positions?

Yourzzz is one pillow that you adjust to your own body at home. It is filled with premium memory foam flakes and polyester fibers. Taking filling out makes the pillow lower and softer. The extra filling stays in the storage bag, so you can adjust again later. If you want the pillow higher than it came, extra filling can be ordered separately.

The inner cover is polyester with a memory foam sheet. It has one firmer side and one softer side, so you have a second way to fine-tune how the pillow feels.

The adjustment follows the sleeping position you give the calculator. If you fall asleep on your side but end up on your back, start with the position you fall asleep in. After a few nights, adjust again if the pillow feels too high or too low in the other position. Because the filling is in the storage bag, nothing is lost.

How do you adjust the pillow?

  1. Order the pillow. You do not need to measure or calculate anything first.
  2. Use the calculator. When the pillow has arrived, open the calculator and enter your height (inches), weight (lbs), sleeping position (side, back or stomach) and mattress firmness (soft, medium or firm).
  3. Take out the filling. The calculator tells you how much to remove and shows the final weight of the pillow. Use a kitchen scale. Without a scale, a 200 ml (6.8 fl oz) glass holds about 50 g (1.8 oz) of filling.
  4. Keep the rest. Put the extra filling in the storage bag so you can adjust again later.

The algorithm behind the calculator was developed by Dutch physiotherapist Thijs van der Hilst. You can read more about how an adjustable pillow works and what to expect from it.

What are the key facts about the Yourzzz pillow?

ItemFact
Price$89 per pillow; buy 2 and get 10% off
SizeAbout 25 x 17 in (64 x 44 cm); fits a standard US pillowcase (20 x 26 in)
FillingPremium memory foam flakes and polyester fibers
Outer coverTencel and polyester blend, removable, machine washable at 104°F (40°C)
Not washableInner cover and filling
ShippingFree on all orders
Trial100 nights
Warranty5 years on material and production faults

A few terms to know. For the trial, you return the pillow if you are not satisfied. There is no prepaid label, return shipping is at your expense, and you include the return form. The refund goes to your original payment method 5-7 business days after we receive the return. The warranty does not cover normal wear or changes in firmness. For hygiene, replace the pillow after 5 years at most. Some users replace it every 3 years. You can find more answers on our FAQ page.

Is there more to a good night than the pillow?

Yes. Your mattress, your room and your habits all play a part. If you want to look at the bigger picture, our sleep guide is a good place to start.

Ready to try a pillow that fits both positions?

If you sleep on your back, on your side, or both, the Yourzzz pillow lets you find the height that suits you instead of settling for a fixed one. You have 100 nights to decide.

Order your Yourzzz pillow

After delivery

Once your pillow has arrived, open the calculator. It tells you how much filling to remove from the pillow you received, and you keep the rest in the storage bag.