Best pillow for neck and shoulder pain: how fit makes the difference

Key takeaways

  • Fit matters more than shape or brand: the pillow should fill the space between your head, neck, shoulder and mattress.
  • Your sleeping position and mattress firmness change how high your pillow should be.
  • Yourzzz is a pillow you adjust at home by removing filling, and you can try it for 100 nights.

Why can a pillow matter for neck and shoulder discomfort?

Your neck and shoulder work as a pair when you lie down. If your pillow is too high, your head tips up and sideways. If it is too low, your head drops toward the mattress. In both cases a gap or a bend appears between your head, neck and shoulder, and your body has to hold that position for hours.

A pillow that fits fills that gap, so your neck rests in a position close to how it sits when you stand. That is a statement about fit and support. It is not a promise that pain will go away.

You would not walk around in shoes a size too small. A pillow in one fixed height has the same problem: a store that sells one size rarely has yours. For more on this, read our page on pillow height.

What does research say about pillows and pain?

Pillow research is limited. It does not show that one pillow shape, material or height suits everyone. Neck and shoulder pain also has many causes, such as posture during the day, desk work, lifting, stress, an old injury or the way a joint moves. A pillow is one factor you can change, and it will not fix the others.

Be wary of any pillow that claims to remove the cause of your pain. What a pillow can reasonably do is support your head and neck in a comfortable position that suits your body.

How does your sleeping position change what you need?

The same pillow behaves differently depending on how you lie. Use this table as a starting point.

Sleeping positionWhat to look at
SideYour shoulder and ear are far apart, so the pillow usually needs more height. If it is too low, your head sinks toward the mattress. If it is too high, your head tilts up and away from your shoulder.
BackYour head needs support without being pushed forward. A pillow that is too high can tip your chin toward your chest.
StomachYour head is turned to one side for hours. A lower, softer pillow keeps your neck from bending back as much.

If you change position during the night, choose a height you can live with in your main position. We cover this in more detail for side sleepers, and our general sleep guide explains how position, mattress and pillow work together.

Does your mattress matter too?

Yes. On a soft mattress your shoulder sinks in, which leaves less distance to fill between your shoulder and your head. On a firm mattress your shoulder stays higher, so a side sleeper usually needs more pillow height. If you sleep on your side and your shoulder feels pinched or sore, the pillow and the mattress are both worth checking.

That is why Yourzzz asks for your mattress firmness (soft, medium or firm) along with your height, weight and sleeping position.

What should you look for in a pillow if your neck and shoulders feel sore?

  • Adjustable height. You can lower a pillow that is too high. It is much harder to fix a pillow that is too low or too stiff.
  • A filling you can change. Shredded fill lets you take out or add material in small amounts. See our page on shredded memory foam pillows.
  • Support that matches your position. Side, back and stomach sleepers need different heights.
  • A trial period. You only know whether a pillow works after several nights in your own bed.
  • A cover you can wash. A removable cover keeps the pillow fresh.

If you wake up stiff, our guide on waking up with neck pain lists what you can check. Our page on pillows and neck pain goes deeper on the neck alone.

How is the Yourzzz pillow adjusted?

Yourzzz is one pillow that you adjust to your own body. The algorithm was developed by Dutch physiotherapist Thijs van der Hilst. You order the pillow first. Once it has arrived, you use the calculator to find out how much filling to remove.

  1. Order the pillow. You do not need to measure anything before you order.
  2. Use the calculator. When the pillow has arrived, go to the calculator and enter your height (inches), weight (lbs), sleeping position (side, back or stomach) and mattress firmness (soft, medium or firm).
  3. Take out the filling. Remove the recommended amount using a kitchen scale. The calculator also shows the final weight of your pillow. Without a scale, a 200 ml (6.8 fl oz) glass holds about 50 g (1.8 oz) of filling.
  4. Keep the rest. Store the extra filling in the storage bag, so you can adjust again later if your mattress, position or needs change.

Removing filling makes the pillow lower and softer. If you want it higher, extra filling can be ordered separately.

The pillow at a glance

ItemFact
Price$89 per pillow; buy 2 pillows and get 10% off
ShippingFree on all orders
SizeAbout 25 x 17 in (64 x 44 cm); fits a standard US pillowcase (20 x 26 in)
FillingPremium memory foam flakes and polyester fibers
Inner coverPolyester with a memory foam sheet: one firmer side and one softer side
Outer coverTencel and polyester blend, removable, machine washable at 104°F (40°C)
Not washableInner cover and filling
Trial100 nights
Warranty5 years on material and production faults

The inner cover has a firmer side and a softer side, so you can try both during your trial. For how adjustable pillows work in general, see our page on adjustable pillows.

What if the pillow does not suit you?

You have 100 nights to decide. If you are not satisfied, you can return the pillow. There is no prepaid label, so return shipping is at your expense, and you include the return form. The refund goes to your original payment method 5 to 7 business days after we receive the pillow.

Normal wear and changes in firmness are not covered by the 5-year warranty. For hygiene, replace the pillow after 5 years at most. Some users replace it every 3 years.

When should you see a healthcare provider?

A pillow will not help with every kind of pain. See a doctor or other healthcare provider if:

  • your pain started after a fall, accident or injury;
  • you feel numbness, tingling or weakness in your arms or hands;
  • the pain is severe, keeps getting worse or wakes you at night;
  • the pain does not improve over several weeks, even after you change your pillow.

If your provider or a physiotherapist gives you advice on sleeping position, follow it. A pillow that fits can support that advice, but it does not replace it.

Ready to try a pillow that adjusts to you?

Order the Yourzzz pillow for $89, with free shipping and a 100-night trial. Order your Yourzzz pillow.

After delivery

Once your pillow has arrived, open the calculator. It tells you how much filling to remove from the pillow you received, based on your height, weight, sleeping position and mattress firmness.